Shared Mailbox Emails Saved in Your Sent Items? Fix It
You send an email from info@ or accounts@, and the copy sits in your own Sent Items. Nobody else on the team can see what went out. This is the default, not a fault. One setting on the shared mailbox changes it. Here is how I fix it, in order.
Quick answer
Sent from a shared mailbox but the copy lands in your own Sent Items? Turn on the two copy settings in the admin center or PowerShell and test it properly.
Video transcript
Shared mailbox emails landing in your own Sent Items? Here's the fix.
Meet Tom Hayes, accounts manager at Brightwater Supplies in Melbourne. He sends invoices from the shared accounts mailbox. His colleague Chloe can't see them. They're in Tom's own Sent Items.
First, why. Exchange saves the copy in the Sent Items of whoever pressed send. The shared mailbox is only the address on the from line.
Second, turn it on. In the admin center, open the shared mailbox, edit sent items, and switch on both copy options. Then save.
Third, or use PowerShell. Run Set Mailbox with the two message copy switches set to true, then check them with Get Mailbox. Do it once for each shared mailbox.
Fourth, turn on both. Send As and Send on Behalf each have their own switch. Miss one, and those emails still go astray.
Fifth, test it. Send from the shared address, then check its Sent Items. Give it a little time, and restart Outlook.
Sixth, old emails. The setting only covers new ones, so drag the old ones across by hand.
Chloe finds the Dalton invoice straight away. My tip: agree one way of sending, and write it down for the team.
The full guide, with every command ready to copy, is free at winstack365.com.
1. Why the copy goes to your Sent Items
By default, Exchange Online saves the copy of a message in the Sent Items folder of the person who pressed Send. The shared mailbox is only the address on the From line. So the person who sent it can see it, and everyone else cannot.
The fix is a setting on the shared mailbox that tells Exchange to also save a copy in the shared mailbox's own Sent Items. It is off by default, and there are two separate switches, one for each way of sending.
2. Turn it on in the Microsoft 365 admin center
You need to be an admin for this. Sign in to the Microsoft 365 admin center and go to Teams & groups, then Shared mailboxes. Select the mailbox, find the Sent items setting and choose Edit. Turn on the copy option for messages sent as the mailbox and the one for messages sent on behalf of the mailbox, then save.
Menu names move around a little between releases. If you cannot find it, use the PowerShell method in the next step. It does the same thing.
3. Or do it with PowerShell
Connect to Exchange Online PowerShell and run this for each shared mailbox:
Set-Mailbox -Identity accounts@yourcompany.com -MessageCopyForSentAsEnabled $true -MessageCopyForSendOnBehalfEnabled $trueTo check the current state before or after:
Get-Mailbox -Identity accounts@yourcompany.com | Format-List MessageCopyForSentAsEnabled, MessageCopyForSendOnBehalfEnabledBoth should show True. If you manage several shared mailboxes, run the Set command for each one. The setting belongs to the mailbox, not to the user.
4. Send As or Send on Behalf: why you need both
There are two permissions that let someone use a shared mailbox's address. With Send As, the message looks like it came from the mailbox itself. With Send on Behalf, the recipient sees the sender's name and the mailbox together, for example Tom on behalf of Accounts.
Each permission has its own copy switch. If only one switch is on, emails sent the other way still land in the sender's Sent Items. That is the most common reason this fix seems to work for some people and not others. Turning both on removes the guesswork.
5. Test it and give it time
Send a test email from the shared mailbox in Outlook, using the From box. Then open the shared mailbox itself and look in its Sent Items folder. The change can take a while to apply after you save it, so if the first test fails, wait a short time, restart Outlook and test again before you change anything else.
Check the sender too. Someone who has neither Send As nor Send on Behalf cannot send from the mailbox at all, so confirm the permission in the Exchange admin center under Recipients, then Mailboxes, then the Delegation tab.
6. What about the emails already sent?
The setting only affects new messages. Emails sent before you turned it on stay in the individual users' Sent Items. If the team needs them in one place, ask each person to drag the relevant messages from their own Sent Items into the Sent Items folder of the shared mailbox in Outlook. It is manual, so do it once, soon after you switch the setting on.
7. If it still goes to the wrong place
Check which way people are sending. In Outlook, picking the shared address in the From box is not the same as opening the shared mailbox and sending from inside it. Both are fine once the copy settings are on, but they are the first thing to compare when one person's emails behave differently.
Want this done for you?
I build this for clients every week. Book a free 30-minute call and I'll tell you exactly what your team needs.